I'd like LFO to be the main focal point with 'Loyal Fans Only' underneath or to the right of LFO.  Maybe we can try an acrostic where LFO are vertical like: Loyal where the LFO are creatively done.
                                                                           Fans
                                                                           Only
Since it's a subscription based site, if we can incorporate methods that show security: a lock and key for the 'O' of showing the 'F' as a 'key' with other security symbols within the L, F, and O, that would be great.